Christchurch, New Zealand suffered a 7.1 earthquake yesterday. It appears, remarkably, there there have been injuries but no fatalities. Christchurch is a lovely city on the Canterbury Plains next to the Pacific Ocean. I have found memories of many visits to the city, and have close friends living there. We have been in contact and other than bad damage to their house and the neighbours, all are safe and uninjured.
GNS Science, a New Zealand government-owned research organisation released the following Media Release.
As background, the Hawke's Bay earthquake of 1931 killed hundreds, and raise the port of Napier far enough that the port was too shallow for ships and it silted over. There is now an airfield over what was a port. In addition, the rebuilding that took place in Napier after that quake followed the style of the day, making Napier a center of Art Deco buildings.
Christchurch will recover (quickly), and will continue to be a beautiful city on the plains of the South Island.
At the same time, this is a reminder to all New Zealanders of the importance of earthquake preparedness. Especially in Wellington!
===========================
MEDIA RELEASE
4 SEPTEMBER 2010
CANTERBURY QUAKE THE MOST DAMAGING SINCE 1931
The magnitude 7.1 earthquake that hit Canterbury early today is expected to be the most damaging since the 1931 magnitude 7.8 Hawke's Bay earthquake.
The earthquake, which jolted Cantabrians awake at 4.35am on Saturday, was located 30km west of Christchurch near Darfield at a depth of 10km. It was felt throughout the South Island and as far north as New Plymouth. Damage to buildings and infrastructure in Christchurch and surrounding areas is considerable.
Dozens of aftershocks occurred in the first few hours after the quake and it is likely they will continue for weeks. GNS Science duty seismologist, John Ristau, said typically the largest aftershocks occurred within the first 48 hours of a large earthquake. They generally declined in frequency and size over time.
"A rule of thumb for a large earthquake at a shallow depth such as this is that the largest aftershock will be about one unit of magnitude lower than the main shock," Dr Ristau said. Seismologists say a foreshock of about magnitude 5.4 occurred a few seconds before the main shock. Both shocks occurred in slightly different locations. Seismic energy from the two shocks became entangled making it difficult to pinpoint the size, location, and depth of the main shock. There are several known active faults under the Canterbury Plains and in the Canterbury foothills, but at this stage it appears the earthquake has not occurred on a known fault. Scientists from GNS Science, Victoria University of Wellington and Stanford University in the US have joined colleagues from Canterbury University to deploy about 40 portable earthquake instruments to record aftershocks over the next few weeks.
The GNS Science contingent hopes to have most of their portable instruments deployed around Canterbury by Sunday night. This will mean approaching landowners and seeking permission, as they hope to place some of the instruments on private land. They will concentrate their deployment on the areas where most of the aftershocks have already occurred.
The battery-powered instruments will be left unattended for about three weeks to record aftershocks. Seismologists study aftershock sequences to find out more about the mechanics of the main shock and rupture, and to ascertain if stress in the earth's crust has been transferred onto other faults in the region.
Scientists will also study satellite data to investigate surface deformation in Canterbury as a result of the earthquake. Geologists from GNS Science have travelled to Canterbury to investigate the geological and environmental impacts of the quake, and to undertake a detailed ground study. Engineering seismologists from GNS Science will join colleagues from the Building Research Association of NZ and Canterbury and Auckland Universities to investigate the impacts on buildings and infrastructure in Canterbury to find out how different construction types performed.
The information they gather will be fed into the engineering community to help ensure structures are built appropriately to cope with stresses caused by strong ground shaking. It will also help as older buildings and structures are retro-fitted to improve their ability to withstand earthquake shaking.
Much of the scientific response to the earthquake is being coordinated under the GNS Science-led Natural Hazards Research Platform, set up by the government a year ago to provide long-term funding for natural hazards research. Manager of the Platform, Kelvin Berryman, said post-earthquake reconnaissance was one of the roles of the Platform, as well as developing quantitative estimates of earthquake, volcano, landslide, tsunami, flood, snow, and wind hazards in New Zealand.
"We have an obligation to learn as much as we can from this event to help improve our understanding of earthquakes and their impact on society, and to help ensure that New Zealand is well prepared for future earthquakes," Dr Berryman said. To see more information on the earthquake go to our GeoNet site.
http://www.geonet.org.nz/ Specific information on the Darfield quake can be found here.
http://www.geonet.org.nz/news/article-sep-4-2010-christchurch-earthquake.html
04 September 2010
16 August 2010
Risk of Fraud in CSR / Sustainability reports (the "Balloon")
Risk of Fraud (the balloon)
While this has reduced the opportunity for direct financial statement fraud and misstatement, the concept of the balloon comes into play. Squeeze the balloon in one place, and it pops out in another. Misstatement of business information with the objective of misleading regulators, investors and analysts is a bit like the balloon. Tighter controls over financial reporting decreases the risk of misstatement of this information, but increases the danger of misstatement of unaudited information.
The fact of greater controls does not mean that the number of individuals willing, able or motivated to "fudge the numbers" has decreased, only that the opportunities have decreased.
Let us consider for a moment the reasons that information is misstated in the first place. Managers and executives in companies are given metrics and objectives that they need to achieve. These metrics could be operational, or could include improvements in share price or other external metrics. To commit fraud there need to be three factors; opportunity, reward and rationalization. Increased internal control quality under SOX has reduced the opportunity, but has done nothing to remove the other two motivations. Where the desire is to influence observers of a company's reported value in order to protect or increase personal reward, those who might have manipulated financial statements will find other externally visible measures they can manipulate. Unaudited information such as CSR/Sustainability information provides such an opportunity.
The investment analyst community use information well beyond the audited reports; non-financial or extra-financial information, projections, unaudited segment information, competitor profiles and performance and industry comparisons, to name a few. Unintentional reporting of inaccurate unaudited information can skew investor models, and intentionally misstated non-financial or extra-financial information could be used to intentionally alter analysts perceptions of a company.
Therefore we should not expect the tightening of systems of internal control and the introduction of penalties for the reporting of knowingly inaccurate information in audited reports to automatically reduce the volumes of intentionally misstated information.
To give an example, imagine a situation in which a company commits, at least in a CSR/Sustainability report, to reduce waste water by a given percentage or volume. Senior managers may have parts of their remuneration tied to achievement of these objectives. In such a case there is an incentive to influence reported results. As this information is not audited, but it is reported externally, senior management could decide to manipulate the results for both positive public relations and to meet personal targets and therefore protect bonuses and other remuneration. The resulting reports, while not audited, certainly are provided into a market place with the intent of influencing valuations of the company.
It should also be noted that we expect this risk to have a relatively short life, as we expect CSR/Sustainability information to become part of SEC and other regulatory reporting over the coming years. In the case of SEC registrant companies, the inclusion of CSR/Sustainability measures into mandated reports could result in this information becoming audited information under the reporting responsibility of the CFO or Finance Director. More importantly this information will become subject to two key sections of Sarbanes-Oxley; 302 and 404.
Under section 302 the CFO and CEO need to certify that the reported results are accurate, with penalties for knowingly reporting inaccurate information. Inclusion of CSR/Sustainability information under this section will result in this information coming under significant additional internal scrutiny, and review by the external audit community.
Should CSR/Sustainability information be considered part of the "Financial Statements" (or equivalent) then the creation of that information will become subject to section 404, and management will be required to both document and test the controls over the production of that information. In this scenario CSR/Sustainability information creation will become far more formalized and process driven, with correspondingly greater depth and quality, resulting in consumers of the information having greater confidence in that information.
05 August 2010
Forgetting is not an option
Last weekend I visited Monparnasse Cemetery in Paris. In section 28 there is a family tomb. The top name is familiar to me (and to many others). Subject to false accusations of treason, convicted on false evidence, his sword broken before him and his epaulets torn from his shoulders before being transported to a prison island. Finally rehabilitated, retired from the French Army and died in 1935.
Now look at the name directly below. Look at her age. Then read the line directly above that: "Disparue A Auschwitz".

Now, look at this picture. Potokari cemetery in Bosnia.
Does it matter what religion? What country, or time?
Forgetting is not an option.
17 June 2010
Myths revisited - Sustainability Indices
On April 15th I wrote about 6 recent myths of Sustainability Reporting. One of those myths is that Sustainability Indices list sustainable companies.
My specific comments from that post are at the bottom of this one, or you can read about all 6 recent myths here: 6 recent myths about sustainability reporting
My specific comments from that post are at the bottom of this one, or you can read about all 6 recent myths here: 6 recent myths about sustainability reporting
Well "I told you so" is such a horrible thing to have to say, but the disaster in the Gulf of Mexico has proved the point, and at the beginning of June, BP was removed from the Dow Jones Sustainability Index. Now we just need to see the other Unsustainable Companies removed, or a new category created: The Dow Jones Would Love To See These Companies Actually Be Sustainable Index (the DJWLTSTCABSI - but then, that is probably a bit of a mouthful).
Grist got it right last September, when they asked Joel Makower (of GreenBiz.com) and Auden Schendler (of Aspec Skiing Co) the question - "Is the Dow Jones Sustainabilitiy Index worth a damn?" From my own perspective, the answer is clear - the DJSI (and many/most others), like many/most Sustainability reporting standards, are great for companies that want to put the effort into appearing to be sustainable, eco-friendly, worker/society friendly, etc.
Frankly, I'll be convinced when companies start providing reports fully linked to the DVFA/EFFAS set of key performance indicators for ESG. The guys at DVFA have done a great job of creating a set of metrics that actually do, at an industry level, help report on the range or ESG issues. Will this make them "sustainable companies"? No. But it will help investors, the media and the public gain real insights into the priorities and activities, metrics and performance of companies.
=== Extract from the 6 myths ===
Sustainability Indices list sustainable companies
Every week there seems to be another release of the winners, or top-100, or top-something list of sustainable businesses. There are also the various indices such as the FTSE4Good, Dow Jones Sustainability Index, or any number of mainstream sustainability indices. And every time I look at the lists, they are populated with companies that have produced great CSR reports, not "sustainable" businesses.
As a classic example, in 2009 a press release touted a list of the top 100 global sustainable companies. "The Global 100 includes companies from 15 countries encompassing all sectors of the economy that were evaluated according to how effectively they manage environmental, social and governance risks and opportunities, relative to their industry peers." Thank goodness they declared that this was in comparison to their industry peers.
After all, who would consider Air France to be one of the top 100 sustainable businesses in the world? It is an airline for goodness sakes, a mass producer of high altitude CO2 and high consumer of fuel, in an industry that survives in part on major subsidies such as exemptions from fuel taxes. However, I guess they must be pretty good, when compared to their peers in their industry. But that does not make Air France a “sustainable” business.
Every week there seems to be another release of the winners, or top-100, or top-something list of sustainable businesses. There are also the various indices such as the FTSE4Good, Dow Jones Sustainability Index, or any number of mainstream sustainability indices. And every time I look at the lists, they are populated with companies that have produced great CSR reports, not "sustainable" businesses.
As a classic example, in 2009 a press release touted a list of the top 100 global sustainable companies. "The Global 100 includes companies from 15 countries encompassing all sectors of the economy that were evaluated according to how effectively they manage environmental, social and governance risks and opportunities, relative to their industry peers." Thank goodness they declared that this was in comparison to their industry peers.
After all, who would consider Air France to be one of the top 100 sustainable businesses in the world? It is an airline for goodness sakes, a mass producer of high altitude CO2 and high consumer of fuel, in an industry that survives in part on major subsidies such as exemptions from fuel taxes. However, I guess they must be pretty good, when compared to their peers in their industry. But that does not make Air France a “sustainable” business.
18 May 2010
Congratulations Katherine Anne Roberts
Last night (NZ time) was one of the those absolutely magic times.
Katherine Anne Roberts, my daughter, was awarded her Bachelors in Architecture with First Class Honors from Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.
I could not be prouder of her, or happier for her. She has put in a huge effort, grow incredibly, has become a leader and a visionary. I love her dearly, and am terribly proud.
Congratulations Katherine!
Katherine Anne Roberts, my daughter, was awarded her Bachelors in Architecture with First Class Honors from Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.
I could not be prouder of her, or happier for her. She has put in a huge effort, grow incredibly, has become a leader and a visionary. I love her dearly, and am terribly proud.
Congratulations Katherine!
(It's my blog and I'll tear-up if I want to.)
11 March 2010
8.1 people killed per 1 employee - not your usual CSR KPI
Imperial Tobacco has just released their latest Corporate Responsibility report. Congratulations.
They have even gone to the trouble of creating a GRI Index and declaring a level of B+ for their report. Since the GRI has a policy that no matter how harmful the products of the reporting company, if the company complies with the standard, they can say it is a GRI compliant report. Maybe it is time for the GRI to draw the line - it takes more than ticking the boxes to be GRI compliant.
But back to the Imperial Tobacco report. There's lots of very interesting information in the report - business size, commitment to being a good employer, especially in relations to human rights, health and safety, etc. Indeed, Imperial Tobacco sets out to demonstrate that it is am exemplary employer, business, and indeed investment. My goodness, you can read all the information, or just look at the face of the employees on their website.
But back to the Imperial Tobacco report. There's lots of very interesting information in the report - business size, commitment to being a good employer, especially in relations to human rights, health and safety, etc. Indeed, Imperial Tobacco sets out to demonstrate that it is am exemplary employer, business, and indeed investment. My goodness, you can read all the information, or just look at the face of the employees on their website.
I expect most HR managers would love
to have employees looking so - enraptured
to have employees looking so - enraptured
Imperial Tobacco employs some 38,000 people around the world. They also produced 322,000,000,000 (322 billion) cigarettes in 2009, according to their own figures. This accounts for something like 5.7% of all cigarettes produced in the world.
According to the World Health Organization (WHO) something like 5,400,000 deaths per year (2004) are attributable to smoking. The WHO projects that deaths from smoking will rise to 10,000,000/year by 2020, so the number is certainly more than 5.4 million for 2009, but we'll use the 2004 numbers anyway.
So, 5.7% of the 5.4 million deaths would mean something like 307,000 deaths per year from the company's products.
An average of 8.1 people killed per 1 employee.
I looked, but couldn't find a GRI Indicator for people killed per employee. Strangely I could not find this information in their Corporate Responsibility report.
When it comes to benchmarking, I expect the tobacco industry probably has a better kill per employee ratio than almost any other major international industry.
As for the GRI Application Level of B+, personally I think the GRI should be embarrassed that their standard can be used to greenwash companies that deal in death. If they sold used syringes surely the GRI would say "Wait, you're speading AIDS. Don't justify your corporate responsibility by proving you create a report complying with our standard. You deal in death. Do not use us as cover."
When it comes to benchmarking, I expect the tobacco industry probably has a better kill per employee ratio than almost any other major international industry.
As for the GRI Application Level of B+, personally I think the GRI should be embarrassed that their standard can be used to greenwash companies that deal in death. If they sold used syringes surely the GRI would say "Wait, you're speading AIDS. Don't justify your corporate responsibility by proving you create a report complying with our standard. You deal in death. Do not use us as cover."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

